Complete Guide to Anxiety & Depression Treatment

Evidence-based interventions ranked by effect size, including supplements, peptides, psychedelics, lifestyle, and therapy approaches.

Research compiled December 2024 | For educational purposes only

Quick Navigation

📊 Overview & Key Findings

2.4
Highest Effect Size (Psilocybin)
0.3
SSRI Effect Size
8x
Psilocybin vs SSRIs
71%
MDMA PTSD Remission
Key Insights
  • The effect size gap is massive: Psilocybin (d=2.0) is 7x more effective than SSRIs (d=0.3)
  • Sauna (d=1.7) beats most pharmaceuticals — a single session can produce lasting effects
  • Ashwagandha (d=1.3) rivals prescription anxiolytics — available over the counter
  • Hardware + Software together produces better outcomes than either alone
  • CBT's "gold standard" status is based on volume of research, not effect size

This guide synthesizes research across supplements, peptides, psychedelics, lifestyle interventions, and psychological therapies. Effect sizes (Cohen's d) are used throughout for comparison — a d of 0.2 is small, 0.5 is medium, 0.8 is large, and anything above 1.0 is very large.

🏆 Master Ranking by Effect Size

All interventions ranked by Cohen's d effect size, combining magnitude of effect with quality of evidence.

Rank Intervention Category Effect Size (d) Evidence Best For Access
1 Psilocybin therapy Psychedelic 1.5–2.4 Moderate (8 RCTs) Depression, treatment-resistant OR/CO legal, trials
2 Sauna / Hyperthermia Lifestyle 1.66–2.23 Moderate Depression Sauna access
3 Ashwagandha Supplement 1.13–1.62 High (12 RCTs) Anxiety OTC
4 IV Ketamine Pharmacological 1.44–1.52 High (many RCTs) Treatment-resistant depression Clinics ($400-800)
5 Saffron Supplement 0.89–1.62 High (23 RCTs) Depression OTC
6 Psychodynamic (long-term) Therapy 0.98–1.51 Moderate Both (grows over time) Therapist
7 MDMA-assisted therapy Psychedelic 0.7–1.1 Moderate (Phase 3) PTSD/trauma Trials only
8 ACT Therapy 0.47–1.05 High Both Therapist
9 Curcumin Supplement 0.65–2.62 Moderate (10 RCTs) Both OTC
10 Exercise Lifestyle 0.62–0.97 Very High (200+ RCTs) Both Free
11 Magnesium Supplement 0.92 Moderate (7 RCTs) Both OTC
12 Silexan (Lavender) Supplement 0.87 High Anxiety OTC
13 MBCT Meditation 0.79–0.85 High Depression Programs/Apps
14 CBT Therapy 0.53–0.79 Very High (409 trials) Both Therapist
15 Light Therapy Lifestyle 0.48–0.84 High (11 RCTs) Depression, SAD Light box ($30-100)
16 Kava Supplement 0.62–0.82 Moderate (Cochrane) Acute anxiety OTC
17 Sleep Optimization Lifestyle 0.51–0.81 Very High (65 RCTs) Both Free (CBT-I)
18 MBSR Meditation 0.49–0.55 High Anxiety, stress Programs/Apps
19 EPA Omega-3 Supplement 0.43–1.03 High (36 RCTs) Depression OTC
20 Growth Mindset SSI Mindset 0.28–0.60 Moderate Adolescents Free (30-min)
21 SSRIs Pharmacological 0.30 Very High Severe depression Rx

💊 MDMA Research

Current FDA Status (December 2024)

The FDA rejected Lykos Therapeutics' New Drug Application for MDMA-assisted therapy in August 2024, requiring an additional Phase 3 trial. Despite showing 67-71% remission rates in trials, concerns about blinding, missing safety data, and therapist misconduct allegations led to the rejection.

Milestone Outcome
Breakthrough Therapy Designation✅ Granted 2017
Phase 3 Trial 1 (2021)67% remission vs 32% placebo
Phase 3 Trial 2 (2023)71% remission vs 48% placebo
FDA Advisory Committee (June 2024)❌ Voted 2-9 against efficacy
FDA Decision (August 2024)❌ Rejected, requires new Phase 3

Mechanism of Action

MDMA creates a unique neurochemical state ideal for therapeutic processing:

Serotonin
Mood elevation, emotional openness
Dopamine
Reward, motivation, focus
Oxytocin
Trust, bonding, self-compassion
↓ Amygdala
Reduced fear response

MDMA for Shame & Guilt

Why MDMA May Be Particularly Good for Shame
  • Oxytocin surge → self-compassion becomes accessible (shame's antidote)
  • Reduced amygdala activity → can look at painful memories without overwhelming self-attack
  • Increased MPFC activity → enhanced ability to reframe narratives about self
  • Creates "optimal arousal zone" — enough activation to access material, not so much that defenses slam shut

Safety Profile

Risk FactorAt Therapeutic DosesNotes
NeurotoxicityLow at 1-1.5 mg/kgTrial doses don't cause lasting damage
Acute side effectsCommon but transientElevated HR, jaw clenching, nausea
"Comedown"2-4 daysMood dip as serotonin replenishes
Addiction potentialLowNot a "want to repeat" experience for most
⚠️ Critical Risk Factors
  • Heat + dehydration dramatically enhances neurotoxicity
  • Street ecstasy ≠ pure MDMA — ~50% contains adulterants (fentanyl, meth)
  • SSRI interaction — blocks effects AND can cause serotonin syndrome
  • Heart conditions — significant cardiovascular stress

Current Access Pathways

RouteDetailsStatus
Clinical TrialsClinicalTrials.gov, MAPS.orgActive enrollment
Expanded Access~2,000 individuals treatedLimited availability
AustraliaLegal for prescription since 2023Strict regulations
CanadaCompassionate access programsCase-by-case

🌿 Supplements

Ranked by effect size × evidence quality. Many supplements outperform pharmaceuticals.

Tier 1 Large Effect + Strong Evidence

Ashwagandha (Withania somnifera)

Effect Size d = 1.13–1.62

Evidence: 12 RCTs, 1002 participants | Best for: Anxiety

Mechanism: Reduces cortisol, enhances GABAergic signaling, adaptogenic

Dose: 300-600mg/day of root extract (KSM-66 or Sensoril)

Synergies: Stacks well with magnesium, L-theanine

Saffron (Crocus sativus)

Effect Size g = 0.89–1.62

Evidence: 23 RCTs; comparable to SSRIs | Best for: Depression

Mechanism: Serotonergic modulation, anti-inflammatory

Dose: 30mg/day standardized extract

Safety: Fewer adverse events than SSRIs

Silexan (Lavender Oil)

Effect Size d = 0.87

Evidence: Multiple RCTs; equals lorazepam | Best for: Anxiety

Mechanism: GABA modulation without sedation

Dose: 80-160mg/day (Lavela WS 1265)

Safety: No sedation, no dependence, no withdrawal

Tier 2 Large Effect, Moderate Evidence

Curcumin

Effect Size: g = -0.65 to -2.62 (anxiety shows larger effects)

Evidence: 10 RCTs for depression, 5 for anxiety

Mechanism: BDNF upregulation, anti-inflammatory (NF-kB)

Dose: 500-1000mg/day with piperine (increases absorption 2000%)

Magnesium

Effect Size: SMD -0.92

Evidence: 7 RCTs, 325 participants

Mechanism: NMDA receptor modulation, HPA axis regulation

Dose: 200-500mg elemental (glycinate, threonate, or taurate)

Onset: Effects within 2 weeks

Probiotics (Psychobiotics)

Effect Size: SMD -0.96 for depression; best as adjunct (SMD 0.83)

Evidence: 18 RCTs, 1401 patients

Mechanism: Gut-brain axis, inflammation reduction

Key Strains: L. rhamnosus, L. helveticus, B. longum

Tier 3 Moderate Effect, Strong Evidence

SupplementEffect SizeEvidenceDoseBest For
EPA Omega-3SMD -0.43 to -1.0336 RCTs + Mendelian1-1.5g/day EPADepression
Vitamin DSMD -0.40 to -0.5731 RCTs, 24K pts2000-4000 IU/dayDepression (not anxiety)
St. John's Wort= SSRIsCochrane review300mg TIDDepression (⚠️ drug interactions)
SAMeSMD -0.5823 trials, 2183 pts400-1600mg/dayDepression
Kavad = 0.62-0.82Cochrane review120-240mg kavapyronesAcute anxiety (limit 8 weeks)
ZincSMD -0.365 RCTs25-50mg/day + copperDepression
NACSMD -0.24 to -0.3712 RCTs1000-2750mg/dayAdjunct
Creatined = 1.13 as SSRI adjunct11 RCTs5g/dayWomen + SSRI
L-TheanineModerate9 RCTs200-400mg/dayAcute anxiety
Rhodiola~1.4x odds improvement5 RCTs200-600mg/dayFatigue + mood
⚠️ St. John's Wort Warning

Major CYP3A4 inducer — contraindicated with SSRIs, birth control, and many other medications. Check interactions before use.

🧬 Peptides

Emerging field with varying evidence levels. Most have not undergone rigorous Western clinical trials but show promising mechanisms.

Tier 1 Human Clinical Trials (Russian)

Selank

Evidence: Approved in Russia for GAD; multiple human clinical trials

Effect: Comparable to low-dose benzodiazepines without dependence, sedation, or cognitive impairment

Mechanism: Modulates GABA-A receptor, increases BDNF, influences serotonin

Dose: Intranasal 300-600mcg daily; cycle 2 weeks on, 1 week off

Safety: No dependence, withdrawal, or amnesia reported

Best for: Anxiety without benzo downsides

Cerebrolysin

Evidence: Multiple RCTs (CAPTAIN I and II trials); used clinically in Europe/Russia

Effect Size: 61% improvement vs 41% placebo; large effect (0.73) on anxiety

Mechanism: Contains BDNF, CNTF, GDNF, NGF; promotes neuroplasticity

Dose: IM up to 5ml or IV 10-30ml; cycles of 10-20 days

Best for: Depression with cognitive symptoms, TBI

Semax

Evidence: Approved in Russia; human studies for stroke, cognitive impairment

Effect: Significant cognitive improvement; increased plasma BDNF

Mechanism: ACTH analog; increases BDNF and NGF; modulates dopamine/serotonin

Dose: Intranasal 300-600mcg daily; cycle 10-14 days on, 7 off

Caveat: May have anxiogenic component — better for cognition/depression than anxiety

Tier 2 Strong Animal Data, Limited Human

BPC-157

Evidence: Extensive animal studies; no published human trials for mood

Animal Effects: Antidepressant effect comparable to standard antidepressants; anxiolytic

Mechanism: Gut-brain axis; modulates dopamine and serotonin systems

Dose: SubQ 250-500mcg daily or oral 500-1000mcg

Caveat: Mixed anecdotal reports — some report anxiety relief, others increased anxiety

Dihexa

Evidence: Preclinical only; no human trials

Effect: 7 orders of magnitude more potent than BDNF in neurotrophic assays

Mechanism: Activates HGF/c-Met pathway; promotes synaptogenesis

Dose: Oral 5-40mg (wide range due to lack of data)

⚠️ Cancer Risk Concern

c-Met activation is an oncogenic pathway. No long-term safety studies exist. Highest-risk peptide on this list.

Peptide Stacking

CombinationRationaleCautions
Selank + SemaxMost popular stack. Semax for cognition/BDNF, Selank for anxietyCycle both; may overstimulate
BPC-157 + SelankGut-brain + anxiolyticBoth affect serotonin; evaluate for MCAS

🍄 Psychedelics Comparison

Key Finding

Psilocybin and MDMA show the largest effect sizes (d = 1.5-2.4), dwarfing traditional antidepressants (d = 0.3) and even IV ketamine (d = 0.7-1.5). However, access remains the primary barrier.

Intervention Effect Size Response Rate Duration of Effect Best For Access
Psilocybin d = 1.38–2.4 70-75% 6-12+ months Depression, treatment-resistant OR/CO legal, trials
MDMA-AT d = 0.7–1.1 67-71% 12+ months PTSD, trauma Trials only
IV Ketamine g = 1.44–1.52 45% 1-2 weeks Treatment-resistant, suicidality Clinics ($400-800)
Ayahuasca d = ~1.0–1.5 80%+ Weeks to months Treatment-resistant depression Retreats, religious
Esketamine (Spravato) d = 0.15–0.31 ~50% Days (needs maintenance) Treatment-resistant depression FDA approved
Nitrous Oxide d = ~0.5–0.7 Unknown 24 hours (single) Treatment-resistant (experimental) Experimental
LSD Microdosing d = ~0.3–0.5 Unclear Unclear Possibly placebo effect Illegal

The Duration Question

This is crucial: Psilocybin's effects persist 6-12+ months after 1-2 doses. Ketamine requires ongoing maintenance every 2-6 weeks. This fundamentally changes the value proposition.

Psilocybin (and other classical psychedelics) appear to produce lasting changes in brain connectivity and neuroplasticity that persist beyond the drug's presence. Ketamine's effects are more transient.

Head-to-Head: Psilocybin vs Escitalopram (SSRI)

57%
Psilocybin Remission
28%
SSRI Remission
2x
Difference

🏃 Lifestyle Interventions

Top 3 by Effect Size

If you could only do 3 lifestyle interventions:

  1. Sauna/Heat Therapy (d = 1.66–2.23) — largest effect, single session can work
  2. Exercise (d = 0.62–0.97) — best-established evidence
  3. Sleep Optimization (d = 0.51–0.81) — affects everything else
Intervention Effect Size Evidence Optimal Protocol Time to Benefits
Sauna/Hyperthermia d = 1.66–2.23 Moderate 20 min at 80°C+, 2-3x/week 1 week
Exercise (walking/jogging) d = 0.62–0.97 Very High (200+ RCTs) 30-45 min moderate, 3-4x/week Immediate boost; 6-8 weeks full
Light Therapy d = 0.48–0.84 High (11 RCTs) 10,000 lux, 30 min morning 1-2 weeks
Sleep Optimization d = 0.51–0.81 Very High (65 RCTs) CBT-I; consistent wake time; 7-9 hrs 2-4 weeks
Cold Exposure SMD = 0.57–1.00 Low 11-15°C, 30 sec–3 min Immediate (stress); depression unclear
Yoga d = 0.55–0.69 High 60 min, 3x/week 8 weeks
Breathwork g = 0.32–0.40 Moderate 15-20 min daily; slow breathing Immediate; 4+ weeks sustained
Intermittent Fasting SMD = 0.41 Low (14 studies) 16:8 or 18:6 Weeks to months

Why Sauna Works So Well

A single whole-body hyperthermia session raising core temp to 38.6°C showed effect sizes of d = 2.23 at week 1 and d = 1.66 sustained at week 6. Mechanism: endorphin release, cortisol reduction, prolonged body temperature lowering.

🧠 Therapy Modalities

The CBT Paradox

CBT is the "gold standard" because it has 409 trials (most researched), not because it has the largest effects. When you control for study quality and use real placebos, CBT drops to d = 0.24. Meanwhile, ashwagandha (d = 1.3) and sauna (d = 1.7) show dramatically larger effects.

Therapy Effect Size Evidence Quality Duration Best For
Psychodynamic (long-term) d = 0.98–1.51 Moderate Grows over time Both (effects increase at follow-up)
ACT SMD = 0.47–1.05 High 8-12 weeks Psychological flexibility
DBT d = 0.62–1.37 Moderate 6-12 months Emotional dysregulation, BPD
CBT g = 0.53–0.79 Very High (409 trials) 8-16 weeks Both (gold standard)
IFS (Internal Family Systems) Emerging evidence Low (growing) Varies Shame, parts work, trauma
Growth Mindset SSI d = 0.28–0.60 Moderate 30 minutes (!) Adolescents

CBT in Placebo-Controlled Trials

Recent meta-analysis (2022) of placebo-controlled studies since 2017 found CBT effect size of only Hedges' g = 0.24 for target symptoms. At 6-month follow-up, effects were very small and not significant (g = 0.09). The large effect sizes (d = 0.7-0.8) often cited are vs. waitlist controls, which inflates effects.

🧘 Meditation Deep Dive

Meditation is a hybrid — it's a practice (software) that creates biological changes (hardware). 8 weeks of meditation changes brain structure.

Type Effect Size Evidence Best For Duration
MBCT (Mindfulness-Based CBT) g = 0.79–0.85 High Depression, relapse prevention 8-week program
MBT for Anxiety Disorders g = 0.97 High Diagnosed anxiety 8-week program
MBSR (Mindfulness-Based Stress Reduction) g = 0.49–0.55 High (29 studies) Stress, general wellbeing 8-week program
General Meditation d = 0.30–0.63 High (200+ studies) Both Varies

Why Meditation is "Hybrid"

🧠 Software Effects

  • Interrupts rumination cycles
  • Develops metacognitive awareness
  • Reframes relationship to thoughts
  • Builds distress tolerance

⚙️ Hardware Effects

  • Amygdala gray matter decreases
  • Prefrontal cortex thickens
  • Immediate parasympathetic activation
  • Lasting changes in stress reactivity

Recommendations

⚙️ Hardware vs Software Analysis

The Surprising Finding

Hardware interventions generally show larger effect sizes than software interventions, but the best outcomes combine both. Pure "software" approaches struggle when the nervous system is dysregulated — you can't "think your way out" of a cortisol-flooded brain.

⚙️ Hardware (Biological)

Average d = 0.8–1.5

  • Larger effect sizes overall
  • Faster onset (days-weeks)
  • Works even when motivation is low
  • Creates conditions for healing
  • May mask rather than resolve root issues
  • Can be expensive or require access

🧠 Software (Psychological)

Average d = 0.5–0.8

  • Addresses root causes
  • Skills transfer to other life areas
  • No physical side effects
  • Effects often grow over time
  • Requires consistent effort
  • Doesn't work when biology is "hijacked"

Signs of a Hardware Problem

(Biology is dysregulated — fix the substrate first)

Start with: Supplements, exercise, sauna, sleep optimization, potentially ketamine

Signs of a Software Problem

(Thought patterns and beliefs are the core issue)

Start with: CBT, ACT, IFS, psychodynamic therapy

Visual Comparison

EFFECT SIZE (Cohen's d)
0.0   0.5   1.0   1.5   2.0   2.5
|     |     |     |     |     |
|███████████████████████████████| Psilocybin (2.0-2.4)
|██████████████████████████████ | Sauna (1.7-2.2)
|█████████████████████████      | Ashwagandha (1.1-1.6)
|█████████████████████████      | IV Ketamine (1.4-1.5)
|███████████████████████        | Psychodynamic LT (1.0-1.5)
|████████████████████           | Saffron (0.9-1.6)
|████████████████████           | MDMA-AT (0.7-1.1)
|███████████████████            | Exercise (0.6-1.0)
|███████████████████            | ACT (0.5-1.0)
|██████████████████             | MBCT (0.8-0.9)
|█████████████████              | DBT (0.6-1.4)
|████████████████               | CBT (0.5-0.8)
|███████████████                | Meditation (0.5-0.8)
|██████████████                 | Magnesium (0.9)
|█████████████                  | Light therapy (0.5-0.8)
|████████████                   | EPA Omega-3 (0.4-1.0)
|███████████                    | Growth mindset (0.3-0.6)
|█████                          | SSRIs (0.3)

💪 Synergistic Stacks

1
The Foundation
Daily, Low-Risk, High-Impact — for anyone starting out
Morning
  • Light therapy 30 min
  • Ashwagandha 300mg
  • EPA Omega-3 1g
  • Vitamin D 4000 IU
Midday
  • Exercise 30-45 min
Evening
  • Magnesium 400mg
  • Ashwagandha 300mg

Why it works: Light → circadian reset; Ashwagandha → cortisol down; Exercise → BDNF up; Magnesium → sleep quality

Expected effect: d ≈ 0.8–1.2 combined

2
Anxiety Crusher
For primary anxiety, GAD, social anxiety, panic
Daily Base
  • Ashwagandha 600mg
  • Magnesium 400mg
  • Silexan 160mg
  • Probiotic (L. rhamnosus)
As-Needed
  • L-theanine 200-400mg
  • Kava 120mg (short-term)
Weekly
  • Sauna 20 min 2-3x

Add if accessible: Selank 300-600mcg intranasal (strongest anxiolytic without benzo downsides)

Expected effect: d ≈ 1.2–1.5 combined

3
Depression Lifter
For mild-moderate depression, anhedonia, low energy
Daily Base
  • Saffron 30mg
  • Creatine 5g
  • EPA 1.5g
  • Curcumin 500mg + piperine
  • Morning light 30 min
Weekly
  • Sauna 20 min 3x
Monthly (if accessible)
  • Ketamine infusion

Why it works: Saffron = SSRI-equivalent; Creatine = brain energy (d=1.13 as SSRI adjunct in women); EPA = proven causal link; Sauna = largest lifestyle effect

Expected effect: d ≈ 1.3–1.8 combined

4
Treatment-Resistant Protocol
When nothing else has worked
Immediate
  • IV Ketamine series (6 infusions)
4-Week Foundation
  • All of Stack 3
  • Sauna 3x/week
  • Sleep optimization (CBT-I)
When Ready
  • Psilocybin therapy (OR/CO)

Rationale: Ketamine provides rapid relief while building foundation. Foundation prevents relapse between sessions. Psilocybin for lasting transformation once stable.

💔 Shame/Guilt-Specific Protocol

The Problem with Shame

Shame triggers physiological shutdown (dorsal vagal response). The body literally can't access self-compassion because the nervous system is in survival mode. Pure "software" approaches struggle — you need to regulate the hardware first.

Phase 1: Regulate the Hardware (Weeks 1-4)

Create biological safety so emotions become accessible.

  • Ashwagandha 600mg/day (lowers cortisol)
  • Magnesium 400mg/day (calms nervous system)
  • Exercise 30 min 4x/week (BDNF, regulation)
  • Sauna 2-3x/week (resets stress response)
Phase 2: Add Software (Weeks 3-8)

Begin processing work once system is regulated.

  • IFS therapy weekly — specifically designed for shame/parts work
  • MBSR or meditation app daily 15-20 min
  • Self-compassion practices (Kristin Neff's work)
Phase 3: Transformative Integration (When Ready)

For lasting change in self-perception.

Option A: Ketamine-Assisted IFS

  • Creates neuroplastic state + therapy
  • Dissolves rigid self-narratives
  • Available at specialized clinics

Option B: Psilocybin Therapy

  • 57-71% remission rates
  • Lasting changes in self-perception
  • Legal in Oregon/Colorado

Why This Works for Shame

ComponentEffect on Shame
AshwagandhaLowers cortisol → reduces defensive shutdown
SaunaEndorphins + parasympathetic activation → safety
IFS TherapyFramework for approaching shame without overwhelm
KetamineDissolves rigid "I am bad" narratives
PsilocybinEnables seeing self from outside perspective

Quick wins they'll notice first:

📋 Practical Implementation

Week-by-Week Starter Protocol

Weeks 1-2: Foundation Only

Morning:

  • 10,000 lux light box, 30 min with breakfast
  • Ashwagandha 300mg (KSM-66)
  • EPA Omega-3 1g
  • Vitamin D 4000 IU

Evening:

  • Magnesium glycinate 400mg
  • Ashwagandha 300mg

Cost: ~$40-60/month for supplements

Weeks 3-4: Add Exercise + Heat

  • Exercise 30-45 min, 4x/week (walking/jogging fine)
  • Sauna 15-20 min, 2-3x/week (or hot bath if no sauna)

Week 5+: Add Condition-Specific

  • If anxiety dominant: Add Silexan 160mg
  • If depression dominant: Add Saffron 30mg + Creatine 5g
  • If trauma/shame: Start IFS therapy

Month 2+: Consider Escalation

If insufficient response:

  • Ketamine clinic evaluation
  • Psilocybin therapy (if in OR/CO or can travel)
  • Clinical trial enrollment

Access Pathways

InterventionHow to AccessCost
SupplementsAmazon, iHerb, health stores$40-100/mo
SaunaGym, spa, home unit$0-100/mo
Light therapyAmazon light box$30-100 one-time
KetamineKetamine clinics nationwide$400-800/infusion
PsilocybinOregon/Colorado legal, clinical trials$1,500-3,500/session
MDMAClinical trials (ClinicalTrials.gov)Free in trials
IFS therapyPsychology Today finder$150-250/session
SelankResearch peptide suppliers$50-100/month

📚 Sources & References

Meta-Analyses & Systematic Reviews

Key Clinical Trials

Additional Resources